|
From teacher to friend: The evolving nature of the coach-athlete relationship
ROBERTA ANTONINI PHILIPPE*, SAM S. SAGAR**, SOPHIE HUGUET***,
YVAN PAQUET****, and SOPHIA JOWETT*****
* Institute of Movement Sciences and Sport Medicine, University of Geneva, Switzerland
** Leeds Metropolitan University, United Kingdom
*** Université Henri Poincaré Nancy, France
**** University of Reunion, DIMPS, E.A.4075, France
***** Loughborough University, United Kingdom
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the present study was to explore the nature and
development of the coach-athlete relationship from the perspective of both an athlete
and a coach.
METHOD: Two coaches (1 female and 1 male; aged 42 and 48, respectively)
and eight elite level swimmers (competing at international level; 4 females and 4
males; Mage18.6 years, SD = 3.1 years) from the Swiss National Swimming team
were interviewed individually. Interviews ranged between 60 and 90 minutes and
were audio-recorded. The athletes and their respective coaches had been working
together for an average of 3.5 years.
RESULTS: Data analysis revealed that the coach-athlete relationship gradually
evolved over time, and that three specific dimensions operated in the development
of this relationship: (1) developing bonds; (2) developing co-operation; and, (3)
power relation.
CONCLUSIONS: The coach-athlete relationship occurs naturally and evolves
over time. This evolution in the relationship is beneficial to the athlete’s personal
growth, mental strength, and athletic development. The study enhances knowledge
and has theoretical and practical implications for the coach-athlete dyad
A case study of the emotional aspects of the coach-athlete
relationship in tennis
SOPHIE HUGUET*, and ROBERTA ANTONINI PHILIPPE**
* Université Henri Poincaré Nancy, France
** Institute of Movement Sciences and Sport Medicine, University of Geneva, Switzerland
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study is to investigate if the concept of transference
developed by the psychodynamic approach is relevant to understand the emotional
aspects of the coach-athlete relationship.
METHOD: Participant is a 23 years old female professional tennis player. Four
interviews were carried out and interpretation was made through a case study
analysis.
RESULTS: The case study gives an insight into her personal history of past relationships
and how transference was central in her relationships with coaches. An
examination of her past relationships and her current relationships with coaches
demonstrated that transference operated in repetition of unsuccessful relationships.
CONCLUSION: It is important to analyse in depth the origins of the quality and
development of coach-athlete relationship. The tennis player’s stories illustrate the
usefulness of taking a psychodynamic approach to understanding the lives of athletes.
Empathic accuracy, shared cognitive focus, and the
assumptions of similarity made by coaches and athletes
ROSS LORIMER* and SOPHIA JOWETT**
* University of Abertay Dundee, United Kingdom
** Loughborough University, United Kingdom
Previous research has shown that a shared cognitive focus between coaches
and athletes increases their empathic accuracy; their ability to accurately infer what
each other are thinking and feeling. The aim of this study was to investigate the degree
to which this association is mediated by an assumption of similarity; the awareness
that a shared cognitive focus exists. 78 coach-athlete dyads viewed video
footage that displayed discrete interactions that had naturally occurred during their
own training sessions. They then reported what they remembered thinking and
feeling while making inferences about what their partners’ thought and felt at each
point. Empathic accuracy, shared cognitive focus, and assumed similarity were calculated
by comparing the similarity of participants’ self-reports and inferences in a
variety of combinations. The results indicated a significant association between
shared cognitive focus and empathic accuracy for both coaches and athletes. This relationship
was significantly mediated by assumed similarity. This suggests that a
shared cognitive focus increases empathic accuracy and that this association is at
least in part due to coaches and athletes recognizing this similarity and basing their
empathic inferences upon this knowledge. These issues are discussed in relation to
limitations, theory, and practical application.
Linking maintenance strategies to the quality
of coach-athlete relationships
DANIEL J.A. RHIND *, and SOPHIA JOWETT**
* Brunel University United Kingdom
** Loughborough University University United Kingdom
This study investigated associations between the use of maintenance strategies
and relationship quality within coach-athlete dyads. A total of 251 participants
(146 athletes and 105 coaches) were administered the Coach-Athlete Relationship
Maintenance Questionnaire (CARM-Q) to measure the use of conflict management,
openness, motivational, preventative, assurance, support, and social network
strategies and the Coach-Athlete Relationship Questionnaire (CART-Q) to measure
closeness, commitment, and complementarity. The use of openness and social
networks strategies were found to be associated with closeness. The use of motivational
and support strategies were linked with commitment. Complementarity was
associated with the use of the preventative strategy. Conflict management and assurance
were found to play more significant roles for coaches than athletes. The implications
of these findings are considered along with some suggestions for further
research.
Influence of desirability for control on instructional
interactions and intrinsic motivation in a sport peer
tutoring setting
PASCAL LEGRAIN*, YVAN PAQUET**, FABIENNE D’ARRIPE-LONGUEVILLE***,
and ROBERTA ANTONINI PHILIPPE****
* University of Reims, France
** University of Reunion,DIMPS, E.A.4075,France
*** University of Nice Sophia-Antipolis, France
**** Institute of Movement Sciences and Sport Medicine, University of Geneva, Switzerland
The purpose of this study was to investigate whether Desirability for Control
(DC) would influence young coaches’ discourse and same age athletes’ intrinsic
motivation during peer tutoring interaction in a sport setting. Fifty-six
participants were selected according to their high vs. low DC score. The following
formula (mean ± 0.75* standard deviation) was used to match participants in similar
or dissimilar DC same-sex dyads in which a coach was asked to teach a technical
skill to a novice athlete. Coaches’ instructional style (support autonomy vs.
control behaviors) was assessed through categorization of verbalizations and behaviors.
Athletes’ intrinsic motivation and their perception of the coach’s intrinsic
motivation were also assessed. Results of qualitative analyses showed that
high DC coaches expressed higher scores on controlling style of instruction and
demonstrations than low DC coaches. Controlling style of interactions was also
higher for athletes who displayed a high DC. In addition high DC athletes were
less exposed to coaches’ demonstrations and controlling verbalizations when they
were paired with low DC coaches. Finally, high DC athlete - low DC coach dyads
entailed the highest scores in the athletes’ intrinsic motivation and in their perceptions
of the coach’s intrinsic motivation. The need to consider desire for control
with regards to pairing young coaches and same-age athletes and supervising
what they say and act is highlighted.
An examination of the interpersonal relationships
of the coach-athlete-peer triangle
ANNE-LINE BALDUCK* and SOPHIA JOWETT**
* Ghent University, Department of Movement and Sport Sciences, Watersportlaan 2, 9000 Gent, Belgium
** Loughborough University, School of Sport and Exercise Sciences, Loughborough, Leicestershire, LE11 3TU, UK
There is less knowledge about the relationship dynamics between peer leaders
with their coaches and their teammates. This paper will examine the triadic
peer leader-coach-athlete relationship. The 3Cs model and its accompanied
CART-Questionnaire wereas employed to assess the coach-athlete, coach-peer
leader, athlete-coach and athlete-peer leader relationships. The sample comprised
460 athletes and 59 coaches who participated in soccer and volleyball. Repeated
measures MANOVA was were conducted to examine athletes’ and coaches’ perceptions
of coach-athlete, coach-peer leader, athlete-coach and athlete-peer leader
relationships. Independent sample t-tests were employed to reveal differences in
perceptions between athletes and coaches. The results indicated that athletes and
coaches exhibited interpersonal relationships to a different extent to
coaches/athletes and peer leaders. Theoretical and practical issues of the results
are discussed.
Reflected appraisals of coaches, parents and teammates:
A key component of athletes’ self?
DAVID TROUILLOUD* and CHARLOTTE AMIEL
University of Grenoble, France
This study investigated some ideas of the reflected appraisal process (i.e., perception
of how others see us) in a sport setting. The first purpose of this study was
to evaluate if athletes differentiated the reflected appraisals of three significant others:
coaches, parents and teammates. The second purpose of this study was to examine
the relation between reflected appraisals of those three significant others and
athletes’ self-perceptions in terms of competence and future progress. Participants
were 368 young adult athletes (Mage = 21.13). Preliminary analyses indicated that
reflected appraisals of coaches and teammates were strongly related, supporting the
existence of a “generalized sport-other” (Amorose, 2003). Multiple regression
analyses revealed that athletes’ self-perceptions of competence were positively predicted
by reflected appraisals of sport-others and parents about competence. Moreover,
athletes’ self-perceptions of future progress were positively predicted by reflected
appraisals of sport-others and parents about future progress and by reflected
appraisals of parents about competence, but negatively predicted by reflected appraisals
of sport-others about competence. Results are discussed in terms of contributions
to the understanding of how coaches, teammates and parents specifically
shape athletes’ self-perceptions.
Perceived coach-athlete and peer relationships of young
athletes and self-determined motivation for sport
ALLISON RILEY* and ALAN L. SMITH**
* Department of Health and Kinesiology, Purdue University, USA
** College of Social Work, Ohio State University, USA
Drawing from the extant sport and social relationships literatures as well as
self-determination theory (Deci & Ryan, 1985; Ryan & Deci, 2007), the purpose of
this study was to examine the association of perceived coach-athlete and peer relationships
with self-determined motivation for sport in young athletes. Basketball
players (N = 211), aged from 12 to 15 years, completed survey measures of social relationships,
including perceived quality of both the coach-athlete relationship and a
best friendship on the team as well as peer acceptance. Players also completed measures
of psychological needs including perceived autonomy, competence, and relatedness,
and a measure tapping self-determined motivation. All three psychological
needs partially mediated the association of the perceived coach-athlete relationship
and self-determined motivation. Competence also partially mediated the association
of perceived friendship quality and self-determined motivation. Social relationship
constructs did not moderate one another in predicting psychological need
perceptions. The results highlight the importance of both coaches and peers to motivation-
related outcomes in youth sport and point to valuable future directions for
sport-based social relationships research.
|