|
Sensitivity to fine-grained and coarse visual information:
The effect of blurring on anticipation skill
ROBIN C. JACKSON*, BRUCE ABERNETHY*, and SIMONWERNHART**
* The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, S.A.R., China
** University of Graz, Austria
We examined skilled tennis players’ ability to perceive fine and coarse information
by assessing their ability to predict serve direction under three levels of
visual blur. A temporal occlusion design was used in which skilled players viewed
serves struck by two players that were occluded at one of four points relative to ballracquet
impact (-320ms, -160ms, 0ms, +160ms) and shown with one of three levels
of blur (no blur, 20% blur, 40% blur). Using a within-task criterion to establish
good and poor anticipators, the results revealed a significant interaction between
anticipation skill and level of blur. Anticipation skill was significantly disrupted in
the ‘20% blur’ condition; however, judgment accuracy of both groups then
improved in the ‘40%blur’ condition while confidence in judgments declined. We
conclude that there is evidence for processing of coarse configural information but
that anticipation skill in this task was primarily driven by perception of finegrained
information.
The influence of processing time on expert anticipation
JOHN BAKER*, DAMIAN FARROW**, BRUCE ELLIOTT***, and JACQUELINE ALDERSON***
* Sports Science and Sports Medicine, Australian Institute of Sport
** Sports Science and Sports Medicine, Australian Institute of Sport
*** School of Sport Science, Exercise and Health, The University of Western Australia
This study investigated the influence of processing time on anticipatory skill.
In a replication of Farrow, Abernethy and Jackson (2005) two different temporal
occlusion paradigms were used to control the amount of processing time accompanying
the appearance of specific kinematic information. A video presented dynamic
images of a field hockey penalty corner drag flick that required expert and novice
hockey goalkeepers to verbally predict the direction of the drag flick at the moment
of occlusion. Prediction performance in a traditional progressive temporal occlusion
approach, where more information is provided in each successive occlusion condition
was compared to a moving window approach that showed the same kinematic
information as introduced in the progressive condition but for a fixed viewing
period. Consistent with the findings of Farrow et al. (2005) results demonstrated
that the information pick up of the participants was similar in the two occlusion
conditions suggesting that it is the kinematic content of the occlusion condition
rather than processing time that is responsible for the anticipatory skill of the participants.
Differences in oculomotor behaviour between elite
athletes from visually and non-visually oriented sports
STUART MORGAN*, and JOHN PATTERSON**
* Biomechanics and Performance Analysis, Australian Institute of Sport, Belconnen, Australia
** Sensory Neuroscience Laboratory, Swinburne University of Technology, Australia
The oculomotor characteristics of elite athletes between differing sports have
been largely overlooked. Instead the research focus has been dedicated to describing
perceptual differences between elite and novice athletes within a given sport. Our
aim was to compare and contrast the oculomotor attributes of elite groups of netball
players, swimmers, and cyclists.We conducted a series of visual search experiments
using a novel task that was unfamiliar to their domain of expertise. These sports
were selected on the assumption they may entail differing visual processing
demands, and that the adaptive visual search behaviour of each on an unfamiliar
task may be different. The results revealed that the elite netball players generated
saccadic eye movements more frequently than both the elite swimmers and the elite
cyclists. Further, the mean amplitudes and mean peak velocities of saccades in the
netball group were significantly higher than in the other groups. Importantly,
analysis of the saccade main sequence showed that the netball group exhibited
higher peak velocities for equidistant saccades compared to the other groups. These
results suggest that there may be underlying differences in both the oculomotor
capability and adaptive search behaviour of elite athletes from different sport backgrounds.
Representative task designs for the study of perception
and action in sport
MATT DICKS*, KEITH DAVIDS**, and CHRIS BUTTON*
*School of Physical Education, University of Otago, New Zealand
**School of Human Movement Studies, Queensland University of Technology, Australia
Empirical evidence indicates that an underlying antecedent of sports expertise
is the ability of skilled athletes to successfully use predictive information to guide
their anticipatory responses. This article discusses the nature of the relationship
between expertise, perception and action using ideas from ecological psychology
(Gibson, 1979) and representative task design (Brunswik, 1956). This conceptual
framework suggests that a shortcoming of many research studies is a failure to accurately
sample the performance environments of which skilled athletes have experience.
It is proposed that the task constraints used to study perception and action
should closely represent the specific performance contexts towards which investigators
are attempting to generalise. Comparison of the research literature using in situ
and video simulation experimental paradigms suggests that athletes’ performance
may vary under different task constraints. These empirical findings need to be considered
in future research on the study and training of perceptual skill.
Developmental influences on the acquisition of tactical
decision-making expertise
JASON BERRY*, and BRUCE ABERNETHY**
* Essendon Football Club, Melbourne & School of Human Movement and Sports Sciences,
University of Ballarat, Australia
** Institute of Human Performance, The University of Hong Kong & School of Human
Movement Studies, The University of Queensland, Australia
The principal purpose of this study was to identify those developmental factors
most predictive of adult perceptual and decision-making skill. Qualitative data
on developmental experiences and social support were collected from semi-structured
interviews of 29 elite Australian Football League (AFL) players, 16 of whom
were independently classified by a panel of coaches as expert decision-makers and
13 as less-skilled decision-makers.While high levels of parental support and a fierce
desire to win, established from an early age, were evident for all players in the elite
sample, the expert decision-makers were more likely to have had (i) extensive experience
of invasion games during their development, (ii) early experience of playing
against adults or older children, (iii) playing experience in related sports (especially
basketball), and (iv) their father as a coach at some stage during their junior years.
The developmental characteristics observed for the expert decision-makers extend
quantitative findings on the practice hours of the same cohort (Berry et al., 2008)
and indicate that observable differences in decision-making skills amongst adult
players, even at an elite level, may be directly linked to each player’s particular
developmental and practice experiences.
The influence of viewing perspective on decision-making
and visual search behaviour in an invasive sport
DAVID L. MANN* **, DAMIAN FARROW**, RICHARD SHUTTLEWORTH** and MELISSA HOPWOOD**
* School of Optometry and Vision Science, University of New South Wales, Australia, Skill Acquisition, Australian Institute of Sport, Australia
** Skill Acquisition, Australian Institute of Sport, Australia
Perceptual-cognitive skill was examined in a film-based task displayed from
two different viewing perspectives. Nineteen skilled youth football players
observed identical simulations filmed from two different viewing perspectives; a
‘player’ perspective designed to simulate that experienced by a player in a game, and
an ‘aerial’ perspective filmed from an elevated position overlying the same location
on the field. Observation of the aerial perspective resulted in superior decisionmaking
performance, most likely a reflection of the additional specifying information
available from this viewpoint. Visual search recordings demonstrated increased
time spent observing open space in the aerial perspective, along with more fixations
of lesser duration primarily due to an increase in the referential fixation transitions
between the player in possession of the ball and other attacking features. For both
perspectives, participants fixated on the correct option however in the player view
this correct option was chosen less frequently.
Knowledge base as a mechanism for perceptual-cognitive
tasks: Skill is in the details!
CLARE MACMAHON* and SUE L.MCPHERSON**
* School of Sport and Exercise Science, Victoria University, Australia
** Department of Physical Therapy, Western Carolina University, USA
Perceptual-cognitive tasks used for both testing and training in sport will benefit
from the inclusion and/or emphasis of knowledge base approaches as a key driving
mechanism. In particular, training and testing of decision making skill is discussed.
The distinction is made between the isolated decision making approach and
the tactics and knowledge base approach to action choices. Knowledge base
approaches are seen to provide a more sensitive and mechanistic assessment of skill
and underlying response selection processes, and are better able to examine individual
differences in the progression from action prediction to action control.
Insights from Ecological Psychology and Dynamical
Systems. Theory can underpin a philosophy of coaching
IAN RENSHAW*, KEITH DAVIDS*, RICK SHUTTLEWORTH**, and JIA YI CHOW***
* School of Human Movement Studies, Queensland University of Technology, Australia
** Australian Institute of Sport, Canberra, Australia
*** Department of Physical Education and Sports Science, National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
The aim of this paper is to show how principles of ecological psychology and
dynamical systems theory can underpin a philosophy of coaching practice in a nonlinear
pedagogy. Nonlinear pedagogy is based on a view of the human movement
system as a nonlinear dynamical system and has been basically defined as the application
of concepts and tools of nonlinear dynamics to coaching practice. A systems
orientation is adopted to show how nonlinear dynamical movement systems
demonstrate an openness to environmental information flows, use inherent degeneracy
to adapt movements to dynamic environments, show capacity for self-organisation,
and fluctuate between stability and instability as changes in constraints on
performance shape transitions in system organisation. We demonstrate how this
perspective of the human movement system can aid understanding of motor learning
processes and underpin practice for sports coaches. We provide a description of
nonlinear pedagogy followed by a consideration of some of the fundamental principles
of ecological psychology and dynamical systems theory that underpin it as a
coaching philosophy. We illustrate how each principle impacts on nonlinear pedagogical
coaching practice, demonstrating how they can substantiate a framework for
the coaching process.
The use of motor learning in Biomechanics:
A call for more collaboration
ALEC BUTTIFIELD, KEVIN BALL and CLARE MAC MAHON
Centre for Aging, Rehabilitation, and Exercise Science School of Human Movement,
Recreation, and Performance, Victoria University, Australia
Though biomechanics and motor learning are complimentary fields of study,
few biomechanists have effectively combined the two. Biomechanics research has,
in general, focussed on measurement techniques and ideal models of performance
rather than how to use biomechanics as a tool to alter technique. Incorporating
motor learning principles into biomechanics research is an important step not only
for the understanding of learning principles but also the utilisation of biomechanical
information in institutes and academies of sport around the world. This paper
will briefly examine how research into augmented feedback, attentional focus and
observational learning can be integrated into biomechanics research to aid in the
successful alteration of an athlete’s technique.
End-point focus of attention: Learning the ‘Catch’
in Rowing
RICHARD PARR, and CHRIS BUTTON
University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand
Initial research evidence suggests that learners may benefit from focussing
their attention upon the demonstrated movement of a distal point of an action, also
known as end-point trajectory matching. In the present study, verbal instructions
were used by rowing coaches to promote either an end-point focus (i.e., the oar
blade) or an internal focus of attention (i.e., the rower’s movements) amongst
novice learners. The goal for the learners was to practice and improve the ‘catch’,
which is the instant that the blade of the oar enters and locks onto the water. The
learners were coached in 24 training sessions over a six-week period, they then
rowed in retention and transfer tests seven weeks later. The End-point group
showed improvements in technique (i.e., more effective and efficient oar placement
in the water) at the end of the skill acquisition period and also in retention and
transfer conditions. The Internal group did not show the same level of improvement
by the end of the acquisition phase but did demonstrate some improvements
by the retention and transfer tests. This study suggests that paying attention to the
end-point is beneficial for novices learning complex, whole body movements (such
as rowing) as well as for relatively simple, precision tasks.
The paradoxical role of cognitive effort in contextual
interference and Implicit Motor Learning
MEGAN A. RENDELL*, RICH S.W. MASTERS**, and DAMIAN FARROW***
* Australian Institute of Sport; Victoria University, Australia
** The University of Hong Kong
*** Australian Institute of Sport, Australia
This paper critically reviews the issues that arise as a consequence of defining
practice conditions in terms of the cognitive effort evoked. Two practice variables
that suggest conflicting implications for cognitive effort are considered: the scheduling
of practice conditions (contextual interference) and the accrual of task-relevant
knowledge during practice (implicit/explicit motor learning). Practical implications
of these two practice conditions are examined, specifically with regard to the
skill level of a learner, the complexity of the to-be-learned tasks, and the ability of
the learner to effectively perform under psychological pressure. It is hoped that
these practical implications inspire researchers to seek more applied outcomes from
their research.
|