|
Symptoms and consequences associated
with three dimensions of burnout in junior tennis players
KATE GOODGER *, LAURA WOLFENDEN * and DAVID LAVALLEE **
*Loughborough University, England
**University of Wales, Aberystwyth
Raedeke (1997) conceptualized athlete burnout as the enduring existence of
three dimensions: physical and emotional exhaustion, sport devaluation, and
reduced sense of athletic accomplishment. The purpose of this study was to assess the
extent to which Raedeke’s conceptualization is efficacious within the context of
junior tennis in the United Kingdom by exploring burned out players’ perceptions of
key symptoms and consequences associated with each dimension. Six former
national junior tennis players who were identified as burned out underwent a structured
interview exploring their experiences of burnout. Content analysis identified
symptoms and consequences specific to each burnout dimension, but also considerable
overlap and interrelationships among dimensions. In more severe cases of
burnout, consequences continued after departure from the sport and were salient in
non-athletic domains. Considerable significance was attached to reduced sense of
athletic accomplishment, diverging from work-related literature where this burnout
dimension is considered of limited importance (Cox, Tisserand, & Taris, 2005).
Athlete burnout and organizational culture:
An English rugby replication
SCOTT L. CRESSWELL *, ROBERT C. EKLUND **
*University of Western Australia, Australia
**Florida State University, USA
Athlete burnout has been postulated to manifest as physical and emotional
exhaustion, reduced accomplishment and sport devaluation (Raedeke & Smith,
2001). Qualitative evidence has recently been presented indicating that this multidimensional
conceptualization appropriately characterizes the experience of athlete
burnout among professional New Zealand rugby players (Cresswell & Eklund,
2006c). The purpose of this study was to extend the work of Cresswell and Eklund
(2006c) to ascertain the extent to which this conceptualization of burnout and associated
attributions were representative of professional rugby players from a different
environment and organizational culture. Overall, the findings supported the contention
that while situational and environmental demands leading to athlete
burnout may vary, the characteristics of the resulting chronic negative experiential
state are robust across settings (Cresswell & Eklund, 2006a; Schaufeli & Enzmann,
1998). Some of the differences in rugby players’ attributions for their negative experiences
were interpreted as reflecting differences in competition structures and organizational
culture.
The process of burnout: A multiple case study
of three elite endurance athletes
HENRIK GUSTAFSSON *, GÖRAN KENTTÄ **, PETER HASSMÉN ***,
CAROLINA LUNDQVIST ** and NATALIE DURAND-BUSH ****
* Örebro University, Sweden
** The Swedish School of Sport and Health Sciences
*** Stockholm University, Sweden
**** University of Ottawa, Canada
The aim of this study was to gain a better understanding of the process of burning
out in endurance athletes. The experiences of three elite cross-country skiers who
left their sport due to burnout were explored. Semi-structured interviews were conducted
and inductively analyzed. The Athlete Burnout Questionnaire and training
logs were used to validate the interviews and to enrich the analysis. The burnout
process was found to evolve with different severity and time perspectives in the three
cases. Athletic identity and achievement strivings to validate self-esteem were found
to be important driving forces in the burnout process. Also, chronic lack of mental
and physical recovery as well as early skiing success leading to high expectations
comprised common themes in the burnout process.
An examination of Coakley’s perspective on identity,
control, and burnout among adolescent athletes
JENNIFER M. BLACK and ALAN L. SMITH
Purdue University,USA
The purpose of this study was to examine Coakley’s (1992) perspective on athlete
burnout among adolescents, which posits that a narrow identity and restricted
opportunity to exert control over one’s sport experience contributes to athlete
burnout. Senior-level swimmers (N = 182), ages 13 to 22 years (M = 16.0, SD =
1.6), completed reliable and valid swimming-specific measures of athlete burnout
dimensions, perceived stress, athletic identity, and perceived control. Athlete training
and swimming performance data were also acquired. Results of hierarchical
regression analyses partially supported Coakley’s perspective. Athletic identity
exclusivity and perceived control over swimming participation contributed 3% to
13% explained variance in burnout dimensions over-and-above performance and
stress indices. However, they did not moderate the relationship between perceived
stress and burnout dimensions. The direction of identity exclusivity findings were
opposite expectations, potentially a result of the cross-sectional study design. Overall,
the results suggest additional youth athlete burnout research targeting identity
and control is warranted.
Does it take three to tango?
Psychological need satisfaction and athlete burnout
STÉPHANE PERREAULT *, PATRICK GAUDREAU **,
MARIE-CLAUDE LAPOINTE * and CHLOÉ LACROIX *
* Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières, Canada
** University of Ottawa, Canada
Athletes who feel autonomous, competent, and related to significant others
in sport should experience lower levels of burnout than athletes whose basic psychological
needs are being neglected (Ryan & Deci, 2002). Moreover, based on
recent research by Sheldon and Niemiec (2006), lower levels of athlete burnout
should also be observed when the three psychological needs (i.e., autonomy, competence,
and relatedness) are simultaneously satisfied (i.e., a balance in need satisfaction)
in sport. The present study tested these two hypotheses with 259 high
school student-athletes attending a sports school. Results indicated that the satisfaction
of each of the three basic psychological needs as well as the balance of need
satisfaction was correlated negatively with athlete burnout. Regression analyses
further demonstrated that the balance of need satisfaction made a significant contribution
to prediction of athlete burnout over and above the significant contribution
of each of the three needs. The present results are discussed in line with basic
needs theory (Ryan & Deci, 2002) as well as the measurement of balance of need
satisfaction.
Athlete engagement:
I. A qualitative investigation of relevance and dimensions
CHRIS LONSDALE *, KEN HODGE ** and THOMAS D. RAEDEKE ***
* The Chinese University of Hong Kong
** University of Otago, New Zeland
*** East Carolina University,USA
Organizational psychologists have proposed that promoting employee engagement
may be an effective way to prevent burnout. Researchers have identified vigor,
dedication, efficacy, and absorption as potential employee engagement dimensions
(Maslach, Schaufeli, & Leiter, 2001). However, no research has investigated athlete
engagement (AE). This study is the first in a series and was designed to ascertain
whether or not elite athletes experience engagement and, if so, to identify common
AE dimensions. Following interviews with fifteen elite New Zealand athletes, AE
was defined as a persistent, positive, cognitive-affective experience in sport, characterized
by confidence, dedication, and vigor. Confidence represented ‘belief in one’s
ability to attain a high level of performance and achieve desired goals’. Dedication
was defined as ‘a desire to invest effort and time towards achieving goals one views
as important’. Vigor was defined as ‘physical, mental, and emotional energy or liveliness’.
Results indicated that AE was relevant to elite athletes and it is hoped that
the findings of this study will lead to research into the promotion of positive sport
environments.
Athlete engagement:
II. Development and initial validation
of the Athlete Engagement Questionnaire
CHRIS LONSDALE *, KEN HODGE ** and SUSAN A. JACKSON ***
* The Chinese University of Hong Kong
** University of Otago, New Zeland
*** University of Queensland, Australia
Building from our qualitative investigation of elite New Zealand athletes
(Lonsdale, Hodge, & Raedeke, 2007), this project had three purposes: (a) to
develop a measure of core athlete engagement (AE) dimensions (confidence, dedication,
and vigor), (b) to investigate the possibility that preoccupation and enjoyment
are also core AE dimensions, and (c) to provide nomological validity evidence
by examining associations with athlete burnout scores. Three studies were conducted
with elite athletes from New Zealand (n = 382 and 343) and Canada (n =
201). In Study 1, analyses indicated that enjoyment was strongly related to AE.
However, contrary to conclusions from our earlier qualitative inquiry, enjoyment
items were not subsumed by the vigor factor. Rather, scores derived from the items
intended to represent enjoyment and excitement formed a separate factor which
was labeled ‘enthusiasm’. This four-factor Athlete Engagement Questionnaire
(AEQ) with subscales intended to measure confidence, dedication, vigor, and
enthusiasm appeared to fit the data in Study 1 best. The factorial validity of scores
derived from the AEQ was also supported in Studies 2 and 3. In Study 3, the nomological
validity of the AEQ scores was supported by negative correlations between
athlete burnout and AE.
|