|
The psychological and social psychological study of football
CHRIS BUTTON
School of Physical Education, University of Otago, New Zealand
The publication of this special issue of the International Journal of Sports
Psychology has been timed to coincide with the staging of the 2006 FIFA World
Cup finals held in Germany. For the 32 participating countries, the World Cup
finals mark the culmination of a 4-year journey to compete at the highest level
in front of the world’s largest sporting audience. The fact that an estimated one
billion people around the world will be watching the World Cup in June and
July 2006 highlights the significant and important contribution that the sport of
football makes on many levels within today's society.
Talent development in English professional soccer
NICHOLAS L. HOLT* and TOM MITCHELL**
* University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada
** Doncaster College, Doncaster, England
The first purpose of this study was to examine psychological aspects of the talent
development experiences of adolescent youth players who were on the verge of
being released by a third division professional soccer club in England. The second
purpose was to compare these findings with Holt and Dunn’s (2004) grounded theory
of soccer success and other pertinent literature in order to present predictions
about the psychological factors that may increase the chances of talented adolescent
athletes making it into professional adult soccer. Nine players (M age = 18.5 yrs) and
three coaches from an English professional third division club were interviewed and
data were subjected to an inductive-deductive analysis procedure as part of the
process of qualitative theory generation. The findings suggested that players lacked
volitional behavior, delaying gratification, determination to succeed, strategic career
planning, coping strategies, and tangible support. We interpreted these findings
against previous research and concluded that hope theory (Snyder, Rand, & Sigmon,
2002) may be a useful framework for understanding psychological issues that enable
some talented adolescent soccer players to make it to professional adult soccer.
Accordingly a revised grounded theory of soccer success during adolescence is presented.
The Psychological and Performance Demands of Association Football Refereeing
DUNCAN MASCARENHAS*, DAVID O’HARE** and HENNING PLESSNER***
* North East Wales Institute of Higher Education, Wrexham, UK
** Department of Psychology, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand
*** University of Heidelberg, Institute of Psychology, Heidelberg, Germany
Traditionally, sports officials have only received a modicum of attention in
sport science research literature. Perhaps more surprisingly, only recently have
researchers begun to investigate key aspects of refereeing performance such as making
judgments, communication behaviors and decision-making training interventions.
With this in mind, we have reviewed the available empirical research into
football officiating performance and where necessary drawn upon other research and
applied programs of investigation in other sports. This paper is structured around the
following key elements of referee performance; (1) judgment of offside; (2) judgment
of fouls and misconduct; (3) control of game procedures; (4) management of the
game and refereeing style; and (5) training complex high-performance skills that
could be applied to the development of football refereeing. We highlight some of the
demands of football refereeing, review the important findings and, with increasing
interest in this area, provide suggestions to stimulate further research.
Interpretation and Application of the Laws of the Game in Football Incidents Leading to Player Injuries
BART GILIS*, MATTHEW WESTON*, WERNER F. HELSEN*, ASTRID JUNGE** and JIRI DVORAK**
* Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Department of Biomedical Kinesiology, Belgium
** FIFA – Medical Assessment and Research Centre (F-MARC), Schulthess Klinik Zürich, Switzerland
This study examined the need for an improvement in the refereeing standard
to reduce the incidence of player injuries during football matches. The FIFA refereeing
department determined a reference decision for 60 player-to-player contact incidents
from the 2002 World Cup. This reference was compared with the decision of
the match referee. All incidents were also assessed by 4 expert panels (i.e. players,
coaches, medical staff and referees). For each incident they had to express the appropriate
sanction (nonfoul, foul, yellow or red card). The FIFA reference decision indicated
that the Laws of the Game are adequate for the majority of situations (70%).
The match referee’s decision was in agreement with the reference in 57% of the incidents.
The level of agreement between the referees’ panel and the reference (60%)
was higher than with any other panel. Post-match disciplinary procedures based on
video replays are discussed to better deal with foul play endangering the safety of the
players.
Perceptions of the Brazilian Football Coaching Staff in Preparation for the World Cup
JOHN H. SALMELA*, MAURICIO MARQUES*, RICARDO MACHADO* and NATALIE DURAND-BUSH**
* School of Physical Education, Federal University of Minas Gerais, Belo Horizonte, Brazil
** School of Human Kinetics, University of Ottawa, Canada
Research on expert coaching remains relatively scarce in the sport psychology literature,
however, some key studies have shed light on the complex processes of coaching
at the expert level. Côté, Salmela, Trudel et al. (1995) postulated the Coaching
Model that represents the mental model and the knowledge and practice of expert
Canadian gymnastics coaches. Since its inception, the model has been validated with
research on expert coaches in various other sports, and skill levels (Gilbert & Trudel,
2000 ; Moraes, 1998; Salmela, 1996). One component of the CM is the coaching context,
or affordances or limitations in the environment, both at the micro and macro
levels. Perceptions of the Brazilian football coaching context were considered based
upon the interview reports of four eminent coaches who were preparing the Brazilian
side for the 2006 football World Cup. The central components of the CM of organization,
training and competition and their views were similar to the literature on
expert coaches. The personal characteristics of expert coaches and athletes were
clearly different from those found with Canadian university and professional team
coaches. These coaches were autocratic, extremely well paid, totally dedicated to success,
and the players respected and complied with the coaches’ demands.
The perceptual-motor regulation of kicking in soccer
BRIAN K.V. MARAJ*, ZACHARY J. MORRISON*, JIA YI CHOW ** and KEITH DAVIDS***
* Faculty of Physical Education and Recreation, University of Alberta, Canada
** School of Physical Education, University of Otago, New Zeland
*** School of Human Movement Studies, Queensland University of Technology, Australia
This paper gives an overview of the coordination of soccer kicking, emphasizing
implications for understanding movement control, learning and development.
While research shows that, at a prepubescent/pubescent age, the level of development
is the most important consideration for the performance of a soccer kick, a
number of factors are related to a more mature kicking coordination pattern acquired
over time. Evidence suggests that the limb used for kicking a ball (dominant or nondominant),
the accuracy required for a successful kick and the velocity of the kicking
leg at ball contact are all major considerations for successful performance. This paper
attempts to provide some clarity to specific issues related to the segmental interaction
of the kicking leg and the degree to which strength of the lower limb influences kicking
performance. Finally, our review of coordination in soccer kicking allows us to
propose the utilization of a novel pedagogical framework (nonlinear pedagogy) as a
basis for interpreting motor system variability during kicking performance.
Does noise provide a basis for the unification of motor learning theories?
WOLFGANG I. SCHÖLLHORN*, HENDRIK BECKMANN*, MAREN MICHELBRINK*, MICHAEL SECHELMANN*, MARTIN TROCKEL*, KEITH DAVIDS**
* University of Münster, Germany
** Queensland University of Technology, Australia
In this position paper we examine whether performance and learning of basic
motor skills in football can be enhanced by adding noise in the form of random components
to target movements during training. To support our argument we examine
longitudinal data on the performance of fundamental target skills such as passing
and shooting. Evidence emerged from these studies that the addition of random variability
during the practice of football skills benefited participants of different skill
levels, compared to players engaged in traditional practice programmes emphasizing
continuous repetition of target movements. The ubiquitous phenomenon of stochastic
resonance is proposed as a potential mechanism for the counterintuitive benefits
of adding noise to learning and performance environments. Further research is
needed to verify our interpretation of these data from football suggesting that stochastic
resonance may form an umbrella explanatory framework on the role of variability
in extant theories of motor learning.
Organization of motor system degrees of freedom during the soccer chip: An analysis of skilled performance
JIA YI CHOW* **, KEITH DAVIDS***, CHRIS BUTTON* and MICHAEL KOH**
* School of Physical Education, University of Otago, New Zealand
** Physical Education and Sports Science, National Institute of Education, Singapore
*** School of Human Movement Studies, Queensland University of Technology, Australia
This study investigated how motor system degrees of freedom were organized
as skilled players performed a soccer chipping task. Using an intra-participant analysis,
inter-individual kinematics and performance differences were investigated to
determine the features governing coordination of skilled chipping actions. Five
skilled participants were studied as they performed 10 soccer chips to one target position
and another 15 soccer chips to three positions, all with different specific height
and accuracy task constraints. Although a ‘global coordination pattern’ was identified
for skilled soccer chipping, subtle inter-individual differences in coordination,
displacement of center of mass (COM), selected kinematic variables for the kicking
limb and the role of the non-kicking limb were also observed. It was noted that participants
were able to adapt foot velocity to different target positions in successfully
meeting the task goal. Results highlighted advantages of examining intra-participant
data for understanding how skilled performers re-organize motor system degrees of
freedom in achieving functional movement behaviors.
End-point trajectory matching as a method for teaching kicking skills
NICOLA J. HODGES*, SPENCER J. HAYES**, DANIEL L. EAVES***, ROBERT R. HORN**** and A. MARK WILLIAMS**
* School of Human Kinetics University of British Columbia, Canada
** Research Institute for Sport and Exercise Sciences, Liverpool John Moores University, England
*** Sport and Exercise Science, University of Teeside
**** Exercise Science and Physical Education, MontClair State University
The aim in this experiment was to determine whether demonstrations that focus
on end-point related information, in this case, ball-trajectory information (BALL), are
more effective in teaching motor skills than more traditional demonstrations which
focus on movement technique (BODY). Nineteen participants with low-level soccer
experience practised a left-footed, soccer-chip shot, which required them to land a ball
on a target, while clearing a height barrier. Information concerning how to achieve the
task goal was manipulated. Participants either received demonstrations of an expert
performing the skill (i.e., BODY, n=10) or they received a demonstration of the
expert’s ball flight path (BALL, n=9). The participants were asked to match the criterion
flight or form to achieve the task goal. Feedback concerning ball flight and movement
form was controlled, although all participants received KR. Trials were videotaped
for analyses and feedback and movement kinematics were collected using 3D
cameras on a selection of trials. Both groups improved during acquisition although
there was no significant difference between the groups in terms of outcome attainment
(i.e., height success and radial error). In retention, the BALL group showed more accurate
performance relative to the BODY group, when demonstrations and feedback
were withheld (p <.05). Only in acquisition were any differences between the two
groups noted in terms of movement kinematics. The BODY group showed a closer
approximation to the model in terms of how various joint displacement angles were
obtained (but not the actual angles) in comparison to the BALL group. These results
provide initial evidence to support the use of end-point template matching strategies
for teaching complex movement skills, such as those common in sports which require
the accurate displacement of some external object (such as a ball or disc).
Visual search and locomotion behaviour
in a four-to-four football tactical position game
GEERT J.P. SAVELSBERGH* ** ***, MONNE ONRUST*, ARNOUD ROUWENHORST* and JOHN VAN DER KAMP * ****
* Institute for Fundamental and Clinical Human Movement Sciences, Faculty of Human Movement Sciences, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
** Institute for Biophysical and Clinical Research into Human Movement, Manchester Metropolitan University, Alsager, England
*** Academy for Physical Education, University of Professional Education, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
**** Institute for Human Performance, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
The present study examined differences in locomotor and visual search behaviours
among a group of skilled amateur soccer players. The participants watched film
clips of a 4-to-4 position game, presented on a large screen. The task for participants
was to take part in the game by choosing the best position for the reception of the
ball passed by one of the players in the clip. A temporal occlusion paradigm was
used: the clip stopped at 80 ms before foot-ball contact, at foot-ball contact or 80 ms
after foot-ball contact by the passing player. Participants’ locomotor and visual
search behaviours were collected continuously throughout the presentation of the
clip. A within-group comparison, based upon the participants’ interception score,
was made. The High-score-group (i.e. participants that moved to the right location at
the right time to receive the ball) had a significant advantage (e.g. more correct interceptions)
when information was available 80 ms after foot-ball contact. No such
effect was found for the Low-score group (i.e. participants that moved to an incorrect
location or arrived too late at the correct location). Additionally, the High-score
group covered a greater distance than the Low-score group both before and after the
player passed the ball. This was independent of occlusion condition. No group differences
were found for visual search behaviour. We conclude that the two groups
used similar visual search strategies, but exploited the detected information differently
to control locomotor behaviour.
Penalty shooting and gaze behavior: Unwanted effects of the wish not to miss
FRANK C. BAKKER*, RAÔUL R.D. OUDEJANS*, OLAF BINSCH* and JOHN VAN DER KAMP*,**
* Institute for Fundamental and Clinical Human Movement Sciences, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
** Institute of Human Performance, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
The intention to avoid a thought or action may ironically increase the tendency
to engage in this thought or action. We show that in penalty shooting in soccer
unwanted effects are mediated by changes in gaze behavior. Generally in far aiming,
people look at where they aim, and they aim at where they look. With an indoor soccer-
penalty task we first confirm this relationship. Next, we show that negatively formulated
instructions not to shoot within reach of the keeper or outside the goal often
direct the player’s gaze to the area to-be-avoided, resulting in more unsuccessful
shots. When visual attention is drawn to the to-be-avoided area there is probably not
sufficient time to redirect attention to the proper location necessary for accurate aiming.
These findings indicate that unwanted effects following the persistent wish not
to miss may increase the probability of missing a decisive penalty.
The "Russian roulette" of soccer?: Perceived control and anxiety in a major tournament penalty shootout
GEIR JORDET, MARIJE T. ELFERINK-GEMSER, KOEN A. P. M. LEMMINK and CHRIS VISSCHER
Center for Human Movement Sciences, University of Groningen, University Medical Center Groningen, the Netherlands
Kicks from the penalty mark (official term for the “penalty shootout”) are regularly
featured in major soccer tournaments to determine the outcome of tied games.
Based on the contingency-competence-control (CCC) model (Weisz & Stipek, 1982),
this study provides an examination of the control beliefs and anxiety experienced by
10 elite soccer players in the context of a major tournament penalty shootout. Measures
included interview questions and CSAI-2R (Cox, Martens, & Russell, 2003)
with direction instructions (Jones & Swain, 1992). The results gave some support to
the model’s predictions. The quantitative analyses demonstrated that perceived contingency
and competence correlated with anxiety. For example, believing that outcome
is based on luck was associated with debilitative interpretation of somatic anxiety
symptoms. Most findings were supported by the qualitative analyses. The
CCC-model can be useful for researchers endeavouring to learn more about perceived
control in competitive sport.
|